One of the few movements that is providing both a critique of the current unsustainable system, and a framework for a system remaining within planetary boundaries is the degrowth movement.
The first International Conference on Economic
Degrowth for Ecological Sustainability and Social Equity took place in Paris in
2008. However, degrowth’s ancestry can be traced further back in time to at
least the mid-20th century with the rise of political parties with
an environmental focus. Those parties often spoke of Zero Growth; today,
of course, zero growth is not enough as the world has seriously overshot many
planetary boundaries. We now must degrow, with the caveat that even this may be
too late.
Much of the focus of the degrowth movement is upon
economics, ecology, social equity, resource depletion, techno-optimism, and
decolonization.
There is one aspect of modern life that gets little
attention within the movement, although (to my mind at least) it is an area of
vital importance. This is the sphere of the ways in which we relate to one
another and our communication styles.
If there is one truism about the predicament we are in
it is that we are all in it together, albeit a few are making themselves offensively
comfortable, some are surviving acceptably well, and lots are suffering
enormously. Given that we are all in this, then it is obvious that we must be
able to talk, listen, and act in cooperative and mutually supportive manners.
Sadly, the signs are that this is not happening, or at
least, is happening far too slowly. Some examples may be of use.
A 2023 UN survey of 14,000 American children (aged 10
– 18 years old) found that 80% of them reported encountering hate speech in the
previous month. In Australia and New Zealand around 15% of adults were
estimated to have been the target of online hate speech in 2019.
Following Elon Musk’s purchase of Twitter in 2022 and
rebranding the social media platform as X hate speech rose by almost 50%.
The number of times that particular words get used
within the English language is revealing. In 1900 the word hate occurred
as a verb approximately seven times in every one million words used. By 1980 its
use had decreased slightly to around five times in every million. However,
since then the use of the word hate has skyrocketed to being used almost
twenty-five times in every one million words used. That is an increase of 500%
in less than 50 years.
One of the distasteful words of the English language
is the word f***wit, which came into the English language around 1970.
It is a derogatory, offensive, slang word mostly directed at another person and
indicates that the recipient of the verbal abuse is considered to be a fool, an
idiot, and very stupid. Although not used anywhere near as often as the word hate
its use has grown exponentially since 1980 and is now used thirty times
more often than it was in the late 20th century.
Even the racially derogatory term n***er has
begun to be used more intensely than it had been. It had been oscillating in
usage of between 0.7 and 1.2 times in every one million words from the 1860s
through to the 1980s. Since 1980 its use began to climb and is now at a
historical high of around 1.6 times in every one million words uttered. Higher,
that is, than the sickening years of slavery in the USA.
What of words that speak more kindly or harmoniously?
Well, some of them have seen rising usage over recent years, although usually
at a much gentler gradient than those referred to above. The word love for
instance has seen a threefold increase in usage since the 1980s – still, much
less than the twenty-fivefold increase in that of hate.
Although there is more use of words such as compassion,
empathy, and kindness in today’s world, the rise of hateful, abusive,
and insulting language is outstripping these by several factors of magnitude.
Disrespectful, vicious, offensive, and rude ways of speaking
to each other have been on an exponential growth curve over the past 40 – 50
years.
The growth in hateful, abusive, and insulting language
spills over into our political, social, and infrastructural realms. Political
polarization is on the rise, fueled by narcissistic leaders intent on using
such polarization for their own power plays. Coexistent with polarization has
come a decrease in trust.
Increased polarization and decreased trust only
exacerbates the use of hateful, abusive, and insulting language as antagonistic
groups of people attempt to shout down those they view as their enemies. In
turn, hateful, abusive, and insulting language helps to create and intensify
polarization. The covid pandemic did nothing to ease these tensions, indeed, it
only intensified the hatred and distrust between people, no matter what
position was taken by proponents of different ways of viewing the cause and alleviation
of the pandemic.
At an international level such polarization and hate
becomes violent and war is the inevitable result. The present war between
Russia and Ukraine is the first on European soil since the end of World War 2
in 1945.
Somehow this growth in hateful, abusive, and insulting
language, polarization, and decreased trust must be curbed. It all needs to
degrow.
I admit that I do not know how that can be done. My
work in community development exposed me to mediation practices and ways of
working that were cooperative and nonviolent. I know it can be done at a
community level.
Can it be done at a national and international level?
More exploration is required, and I would advocate
that the Degrowth Movement consider how to degrow this alarming trend.